ICG 50-Sticks

An Approach to the 'I-CHING'

by Frank C. Fung ( 1st published in December, 2004. )

Top Of Page

Section 6 : { Combinatorial Mathematics } in the 'I-CHING'

Topic IIntroduction & Summary for the Section
Topic IIRecalling the { Ceremony with the 50 Sticks }
Topic IIIThe { 1st Round }
Topic IVThe { 2nd Round }
Topic VThe { 3rd Round }
Topic VIRecalling the Summary Table
Topic VIICalculating the Probabilities ( 1 of 4 )
Topic VIIICalculating the Probabilities ( 2 of 4 )
Topic IXCalculating the Probabilities ( 3 of 4 )
Topic XCalculating the Probabilities ( 4 of 4 )
Topic XIA Statement of the Probabilities
Topic XIIRe-cap & further Questions

Topic I - Introduction & Summary for the Section :

In this section, we shall re-look at the { Ceremony with the 50 Sticks } from a { Combinatorial Mathematics } stand-point.

By the end of this Section, we will have come up with the values for :

This then demonstrates the depth of understanding of { Combinatoiral Mathematics } required for fuller appreciation the 'I-CHING'.

go to Top Of Page

Topic II - Recalling the { Ceremony with the 50 Sticks } :

Let us recall, from Section 4, the { Ceremony with the 50 Sticks }.

Let us also recall that we have identified three (3) spaces, for easier-interpretation purposes :

go to Top Of Page

Topic III - The { 1st Round } :

Let us recall that we started out with { 49 Sticks } in the { 1st Round } , for the combinatorial counting for [ 1st Hole ] in the Box .

The possible outcomes for the { 49 sticks } here are as follows :

Number of Sticks TOTAL in
1st Hole
= { Space-A }
+ { Space-B }
+ { Space-C }
in
{ Space-A }
in
{ Space-B }
in
{ Space-C }
remaining
from the
'take 4-sticks
at-a-time'
procedure
1 1 3 44 5
1 2 2 44 5
1 3 1 44 5
1 4 4 40 9

Several things to note here :

go to Top Of Page

Topic IV - The { 2nd Round } :

Let us recall that we can start out with either { 44 Sticks } or { 40 Sticks } in the { 2nd Round } , for the combinatorial counting for [ 2nd Hole ] in the Box .

The possible outcomes for the { 44 sticks } here are as follows :

Number of Sticks TOTAL in
2nd Hole
= { Space-A }
+ { Space-B }
+ { Space-C }
in
{ Space-A }
in
{ Space-B }
in
{ Space-C }
remaining
from the
'take 4-sticks
at-a-time'
procedure
1 1 2 40 4
1 2 1 40 4
1 3 4 36 8
1 4 3 36 8

The possible outcomes for the { 40 sticks } here are as follows :

Number of Sticks TOTAL in
2nd Hole
= { Space-A }
+ { Space-B }
+ { Space-C }
in
{ Space-A }
in
{ Space-B }
in
{ Space-C }
remaining
from the
'take 4-sticks
at-a-time'
procedure
1 1 2 36 4
1 2 1 36 4
1 3 4 32 8
1 4 3 32 8

Several things to note here :

go to Top Of Page

Topic V - The { 3rd Round } :

Let us recall that we can start out with either { 40 Sticks } , { 36 Sticks } , or { 32 Sticks } in the { 3rd Round } , for the combinatorial counting for the [ 3rd Hole ] in the Box .

The possible outcomes for the { 40 sticks } here are as follows :

Number of Sticks in TOTAL in
3rd Hole
= { Space-A }
+ { Space-B }
+ { Space-C }
in
{ Space-A }
in
{ Space-B }
in
{ Space-C }
remaining
from the
'take 4-sticks
at-a-time'
procedure
1 1 2 36 4
1 2 1 36 4
1 3 4 32 8
1 4 3 32 8

The possible outcomes for the { 36 sticks } here are as follows :

Number of Sticks TOTAL in
3rd Hole
= { Space-A }
+ { Space-B }
+ { Space-C }
in
{ Space-A }
in
{ Space-B }
in
{ Space-C }
remaining
from the
'take 4-sticks
at-a-time'
procedure
1 1 2 32 4
1 2 1 32 4
1 3 4 28 8
1 4 3 28 8

The possible outcomes for the { 32 sticks } here are as follows :

Number of Sticks TOTAL in
3rd Hole
= { Space-A }
+ { Space-B }
+ { Space-C }
in
{ Space-A }
in
{ Space-B }
in
{ Space-C }
remaining
from the
'take 4-sticks
at-a-time'
procedure
1 1 2 28 4
1 2 1 28 4
1 3 4 24 8
1 4 3 24 8

Several things to note here :

go to Top Of Page

Topic VI - Recalling the Summary Table :

Let us now re-look at this table previously presented in Section 4 :

Number of
Sticks
in
[ QI ] or [ OU ]
designation
Resultant
Line
Number of
Sticks
remaining
1st
hole
2nd
hole
3rd
hole
1st
hole
2nd
hole
3rd
hole
after
1st
Split
after
2nd
Split
after
3rd
Split
544 QI QI QI OLD YANG 44 40 36
548 QI QI OU YOUNG YIN 44 40 32
584 QI OU QI YOUNG YIN 44 36 32
588 QI OU OU YOUNG YANG 44 36 28
944 OU QI QI YOUNG YIN 40 36 32
948 OU QI OU YOUNG YANG 40 36 28
984 OU OU QI YOUNG YANG 40 32 28
988 OU OU OU OLD YIN 40 32 24

which is consistant with our findings above.

go to Top Of Page

Topic VII - Calculating the Probabilities : ( 1 of 4 )

We note, first of all, that :

For the { 49 Sticks } Split :

For the { 44 Sticks } Split :

For the { 40 Sticks } Split :

For the { 36 Sticks } Split :

For the { 32 Stick } Split :

Let us now assume, the remaining { 46 sticks } / { 41 Sticks } / { 37 Sticks } / { 33 Sticks } / { 29 sticks } each have an equal probability of going into either [ Space-B ] or [ Space-C ] .

i.e. , for each of the remaining sticks :

( The reader may wish to relax this assumption at a later stage. )

branch to Combinatorics Tables

Based on this assumption, we then provide herewith a branching to Combinatorics Tables for the numbers { 28 } thru { 49 } :

Braching to Combinatorics Tables
for a given Value of [ N ]
The Value
of
[ N ]
49 48 47 46 45 44
43 42 41 40 39 38 37 36
35 34 33 32 31 30 29 28
------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------

go to Top Of Page

Topic VIII - Calculating the Probabilities : ( 2 of 4 )

Let us now focus on :

We then present this Summary Table for the entire range from { N = [ 28 ] } to { N = [ 49 ] } , although the only numbers relevent here are the numbers [ 46 ] , [ 41 ] , [ 37 ] , [ 33 ] , & [ 29 ] , as marked below.

Value
of
'N'
Probability
of
[ ANSB ]
being
equal to
{ 0 mod 4 }
Probability
of
[ ANSB ]
being
equal to
{ 1 mod 4 }
Probability
of
[ ANSB ]
being
equal to
{ 2 mod 4 }
Probability
of
[ ANSB ]
being
equal to
{ 3 mod 4 }
Value of
DELTA
49 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^24 ) }
48 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 0.25
- DELTA
0.25 0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^23 ) }
47 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^23 ) }
46 0.25 0.25
- DELTA
0.25 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^22 ) }
45 0.25
- DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^22 ) }
44 0.25
- DELTA
0.25 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^21 ) }
43 0.25
- DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^21 ) }
42 0.25 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 0.25
- DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^20 ) }
41 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^20 ) }
40 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 0.25
- DELTA
0.25 0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^19 ) }
39 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^19 ) }
38 0.25 0.25
- DELTA
0.25 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^18 ) }
37 0.25
- DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^18 ) }
36 0.25
- DELTA
0.25 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^17 ) }
35 0.25
- DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^17 ) }
34 0.25 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 0.25
- DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^16 ) }
33 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^16 ) }
32 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 0.25
- DELTA
0.25 0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^15 ) }
31 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^15 ) }
30 0.25 0.25
- DELTA
0.25 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^14 ) }
29 0.25
- DELTA
0.25
- DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^14 ) }
28 0.25
- DELTA
0.25 0.25
+ DELTA
0.25 0.25 *
{ 1 / ( 2^13 ) }

We have taken the liberty to mark :

The most important thing to note here is that :

The reader may now notice a { cycle of '8' } pattern in the above table, namely :

go to Top Of Page

Topic IX - Calculating the Probabilities : ( 3 of 4 )

Let us now summarize the probabilities as follows :

go to Top Of Page

Topic X - Calculating the Probabilities : ( 4 of 4 )

For our next table, derived from the 5 tables immediately above, we then set up the following values for easier-notation purposes :

ZETA = 1 / ( 2^22 )
ALPHA = 1 / ( 2^20 )
BETA = 1 / ( 2^18 )
GAMMA = 1 / ( 2^16 )
PSI = 1 / ( 2^14 )

We then have the table below for the probabilities at the { 1st / 2nd / 3rd Splits } :

I.D. Line
Type
# of
stick
at
Split
Probability at
1st split
Probability at
2nd split
Probability at
3rd split
1
s
t
2
n
d
3
r
d
5-4-4 Old
YANG
49 44 40 0.25 *
( 3 - ZETA )
0.50 *
( 1 + ALPHA )
0.50 *
( 1 - BETA )
5-4-8 Young
YIN
49 44 40 0.25 *
( 3 - ZETA )
0.50 *
( 1 + ALPHA )
0.50 *
( 1 + BETA )
5-8-4 Young
YIN
49 44 36 0.25 *
( 3 - ZETA )
0.50 *
( 1 - ALPHA )
0.50 *
( 1 + GAMMA )
5-8-8 Young
YANG
49 44 36 0.25 *
( 3 - ZETA )
0.50 *
( 1 - ALPHA )
0.50 *
( 1 - GAMMA )
9-4-4 Young
YIN
49 40 36 0.25 *
( 1 + ZETA )
0.50 *
( 1 - BETA )
0.50 *
( 1 + GAMMA )
9-4-8 Young
YANG
49 40 36 0.25 *
( 1 + ZETA )
0.50 *
( 1 - BETA )
0.50 *
( 1 - GAMMA )
9-8-4 Young
YANG
49 40 32 0.25 *
( 1 + ZETA )
0.50 *
( 1 + BETA )
0.50 *
( 1 - PSI )
9-8-8 Old
YIN
49 40 32 0.25 *
( 1 + ZETA )
0.50 *
( 1 + BETA )
0.50 *
( 1 + PSI )

We shall now proceed to calculate the probabilities, i.e. :

But for the Calculations Table below, let us first take-out the common factor :

Negative Powers of Two
0 14 16 18 20 22 32 34 36 38 40 42 44 54 56 58 60 62 64 66
5-4-4 Old
YANG
+3 -3 +3 -1 -3 +1 -1 +1
5-4-8 Young
YIN
+3 +3 +3 -1 +3 -1 -1 -1
5-8-4 Young
YIN
+3 +3 -3 -1 -3 -1 +1 +1
5-8-8 Young
YANG
+3 -3 -3 -1 +3 +1 +1 -1
9-4-4 Young
YIN
+1 +1 -1 +1 -1 +1 -1 -1
9-4-8 Young
YANG
+1 -1 -1 +1 +1 -1 -1 +1
9-8-4 Young
YANG
+1 -1 +1 +1 -1 -1 +1 -1
9-8-8 Old
YIN
+1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1
Sum of
Column
16 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

We note here that :

And this is consistant with the fact that we have taken-out the factor of [ 1 / 16 ] for this table, i.e. :

We then arrive, after further calculations, at this Summary Table below :

Probability is equal to :
+ { 1 / 16 } * + { 1 / 16 } *
{ 1 / 2^22 } *
+ { 1 / 16 } *
{ 1 / 2^42 } *
+ { 1 / 16 } *
{ 1 / 2^60 } *
Old
YANG
+3 -37 -45 +1
Young
YIN
+7 +287 -408 -31
Young
YANG
+5 -523 -639 -34
Old
YIN
+1 +273 +1092 +64

go to Top Of Page

Topic XI - The Statement of the Probabilities :

Let us now restate the above probabilities in the more familiar format :

Probability of a { 'OLD YANG Line' } = { 3 / 16 } - 37 * { 1 / 2^26 } - 45 * { 1 / 2^46 } + 1 * { 1 / 2^64 }
Probability of a { 'YOUNG YIN Line' } = { 7 / 16 } + 287 * { 1 / 2^26 } - 408 * { 1 / 2^46 } - 31 * { 1 / 2^64 }
Probability of a { 'YOUNG YANG Line' } = { 5 / 16 } - 523 * { 1 / 2^26 } - 639 * { 1 / 2^46 } - 34 * { 1 / 2^64 }
Probability of a { 'OLD YIN Line' } = { 1 / 16 } + 273 * { 1 / 2^26 } + 1092 * { 1 / 2^46 } + 64 * { 1 / 2^64 }

Incidently, { 2^64 } , in [ base 10 ] , is [ 18,446,744,073,709,551,616 ] , a { twenty-digits-number } .

We can then set up the four (4) values, [ N1 ] , [ N2 ] , [ N3 ] , & [ N4 ] respectively :

N1 = 3 * 2^60 - 37 * 2^38 - 45 * 2^18 + 1
N2 = 7 * 2^60 + 287 * 2^38 - 408 * 2^18 - 31
N3 = 5 * 2^60 - 523 * 2^38 - 639 * 2^18 - 34
N4 = 1 * 2^60 + 273 * 2^38 + 1092 * 2^18 + 64

so that :

Probability of a { OLD YANG Line } = N1 / 2^64
Probability of a { YOUNG YIN Line } = N2 / 2^64
Probability of a { YOUNG YANG Line } = N3 / 2^64
Probability of a { OLD YIN Line } = N4 / 2^64

We note, of course, that :

go to Top Of Page

Topic XII - Re-cap & further Questions :

From a rather simple procedure, the { Ceremony with the 50 Sticks } , we went thru a rather long procedure in { Combinatorial Mathematics } to arrive at four (4) probabilities.

Several questions remain :

go to Top Of Page

go to the next Section : Section 7 - The { Parity of '4' } in the 'I-CHING' & { Non-parity }

go to the last Section : Section 5 - The { ICG Hexagram Placement Scheme }

return to the ICG HomePage

original dated 2004-12-18